Building on the previous post.. Reading Gibson.. I think, unfortunately, that there is good use of communicating an objective and subjective perspective to clarify what there is and isn't. This is an objective perspective in itself. Besides that, consider the point of which misperception of affordances comes into play, just by the word "misperception" there is an implication that -in a subjective perspective we may perceive an affordance, that in actual fact, is not there. Then, it has to have not been there in an objective sense to begin with.
I appreciate the fact that Gibson tries intently to explain and visualise the non-subjective/objective nature of affordances themselves -I am on board here. It's only that, the dichotomous relationship of subj.-obj. bears on the information communicated and is entrenched in the linguistics. I do not think we can escape them unless we resort to dualism in some sense. Each time an affordance exists and not exists it must be said in a subjective sense. Unless, we wish to abandon that specific set of philosophical underpinnings.. is that possible?
[Edit, 12:17, 3/4-2013]
[Gibson also seems to confuse me at times in this area, he speaks of affordances very strictly as relationships in an initial definitional sense, but goes on saying that objects always afford their affordances to actors in a .. behavioral sense? But this is not entirely true, it is not only in a behavioural sense that he speaks of them as retained. He doesn't speak of them differently in separate philosophical terms either (ontologically/epistemologically).. Could it be the distinction between realisation and actualisation that separates Koffka's and Gibson's view here? That Gibson picks up on but doesn't mention explicitly?]
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
a. charles catania
(1)
abstract
(1)
accident
(1)
account
(1)
actualisation
(2)
actualization
(1)
addicted to love
(1)
addiction
(1)
affordance
(5)
affordances
(15)
alternative environments
(2)
alternative objects
(2)
an ecological approach to psychology
(1)
anthony chemero
(1)
anthrocentrism
(1)
anti
(2)
anti-representationalism
(3)
anti-representationalist
(2)
applied psychology
(1)
arguments against representationalism
(1)
atheism
(1)
atheist
(1)
autocatakinetic
(1)
baby
(1)
Bargh
(4)
behaviour
(3)
bias
(1)
Big Bang
(1)
brain in a vat
(1)
british psychological association
(1)
canons
(1)
cartesian dualism
(1)
chance
(1)
chaos theory
(1)
Chemero
(1)
christian
(2)
christianity
(1)
clinical psychology
(4)
cognition
(7)
cognitive
(3)
cognitive psychology
(10)
cognitive psychology in crisis
(5)
coincidence
(1)
computationalism
(1)
computer
(1)
computer-gaming
(1)
conceptual
(2)
conflict resolution
(1)
conflicts
(1)
contrast between computation and ecological strategy
(1)
created depictions
(1)
crib
(1)
critical
(1)
critical realism
(4)
cusp catastrophe
(1)
Daniel
(1)
daniel fishman
(1)
Dave
(1)
definition
(3)
dependence
(2)
depicted environments
(2)
depicted objects
(2)
depiction
(1)
depictions
(5)
dichotomization
(1)
dichotomized perception
(1)
dichotomizing
(1)
direct
(2)
direct perception
(6)
Doyen
(4)
dualism
(1)
dynamic
(3)
dynamic systems
(2)
dynamic systems theory
(1)
Earp
(1)
ecological psychology
(18)
Ed
(2)
elderly
(2)
embodied
(4)
embodied cognition
(15)
embodied emotion
(1)
embodied psychology
(1)
embodiment
(1)
emotion
(1)
emotions
(1)
energy propagation
(1)
english
(1)
ensammast
(1)
entropy
(1)
entropy debt
(1)
environment
(1)
epistemology
(5)
eric
(1)
eric charles
(8)
ethical problems
(1)
ethics
(1)
exemplification
(1)
exist
(3)
existence
(3)
experience
(2)
explanations of
(1)
field potentials
(1)
Foddy
(1)
gaming
(1)
gay
(2)
gender neutral pronoun
(1)
Gibson
(3)
Gigerenzer
(1)
Golonka
(3)
hard sciences
(4)
harry heft
(1)
heterogeneity
(1)
hie
(2)
hier
(2)
hier's
(1)
hierself
(1)
history of psychology
(1)
homogeneity
(1)
homosexuality
(1)
hovind
(1)
how multiple integrations make human intelligence
(1)
human system
(1)
humanity
(1)
i
(1)
I do apologise but
(1)
I'm
(2)
illusions
(1)
individual
(1)
infant
(1)
interception
(1)
introduction
(1)
issue editor's foreword
(1)
John Locke
(1)
joshua w clegg
(1)
kent
(1)
league of legends
(1)
lieberman
(1)
Linda Smith
(1)
link
(2)
logic
(1)
logical abstraction
(1)
love
(1)
lyrics
(1)
lyrik
(1)
master thesis
(7)
matthew
(1)
mental disorders
(1)
metafor
(1)
metaforer
(1)
method
(1)
Milgram
(1)
Milgram misunderstood
(1)
mobile
(1)
modeling
(1)
more than concepts
(1)
Müller-Lyer illusion
(1)
natural science of behaviour
(1)
norman henry anderson
(1)
Nussbaum
(1)
obediance to authority
(1)
objective
(3)
observation
(1)
observe
(1)
occam's razor
(1)
of
(2)
online gaming
(1)
ontology
(6)
overmedication
(1)
peace
(1)
perception
(9)
personality
(1)
perspective
(5)
philosophy
(7)
philosophy of mind
(4)
philosophy of psychology
(15)
philosophy of science
(6)
positivism
(4)
potential
(1)
pragmatic case studies
(1)
prediction
(1)
priming
(3)
programmed depictions
(1)
psychiatry
(1)
psychology
(8)
psychology of philosophy
(1)
radical embodied cognitive science
(6)
random
(1)
reading list
(1)
realisation
(1)
realism
(2)
rECS
(4)
relationship
(3)
religion
(1)
replication
(1)
replications
(1)
representation
(3)
representationalism
(7)
representationalist
(2)
representations
(3)
reproducibility
(1)
research
(2)
retraction
(2)
review of general psychology
(8)
Savulescu
(1)
science
(5)
screen
(1)
screen-presented
(1)
self-development
(1)
self-organisation
(1)
self-realization
(1)
Simons
(1)
simulation
(1)
social
(3)
social construction
(3)
social constructionism
(2)
soft sciences
(4)
sports
(1)
stability
(1)
stanley messer
(1)
statistics
(1)
stereotype
(2)
stereotypes
(1)
study
(1)
subjective
(5)
Sunday musings
(1)
sverige
(1)
system
(1)
task
(1)
task analysis
(1)
taxonomy
(1)
teaching example
(1)
text
(1)
the empirical study of epistemology and phenomenology
(1)
the fragmented object
(1)
the self
(2)
thermodynamic psychology
(3)
Thermodynamics
(1)
thesis experiment
(1)
three laws of information integration
(1)
thunderf00t
(1)
thunderfoot
(1)
traditional psychology
(1)
unconscious
(1)
understanding
(1)
unified psychology
(7)
universe
(1)
unless
(2)
utility
(1)
virtual
(4)
virtual affordances
(6)
virtual agent
(2)
virtual agents
(1)
virtual environment
(4)
virtual environments
(1)
virtual interception task
(2)
Wilson
(3)
world view
(1)
Wudarczyk
(1)
Yong
(2)
you're
(2)
No comments:
Post a Comment